RE: Re: The costs of spiritual faith

From: Antony Davies, Ph.D. (antony@antolin-davies.com)
Date: Mon Aug 29 2005 - 13:16:07 CDT

  • Next message: JeniferGamber@aol.com: "Re: The costs of spiritual faith"

     
    Actually, no. The Christian belief is that God's love is a *gift,* not a
    purchased product -- i.e. there is no price that we are required to pay.
     
    There is, however, what one might characterize as an externality. The
    recognition of Divine love usually creates in people a sense of obligation.
    Hence, people come to feel that it would be wrong to covet their neighbors'
    wives. For those who enjoy the coveting, the recognition of Divine love may
    impose a negative externality. Such people would likely choose to believe
    that there is no Divine love (the atheist position), or that the rejection
    of Divine acceptance is the price one pays for the "right" to covet the
    neighbor's wife (the "I'm going to hell crowd").
     
    Antony Davies
     
     
     

    -----Original Message-----
    From: Jim Eaton [mailto:jeaton@Bridgewater.EDU]
    Sent: Monday, August 29, 2005 2:06 PM
    To: tch-econ@elon.edu
    Subject: RE: Re: The costs of spiritual faith

    At 05:38 PM 8/27/2005 -0500, Lee Erickson wrote:

    The key to making economic sense of God's love is to view it as a pure
    public good. Gods love is not rival in consumption, so the number of
    conversions available is not finite. Whosoever will may come. The free
    gift of salvation is available to everyone, because God paid for it. Theres
    no free lunch, but there is a public good.

    OK, so God's love is a public good. But is it truly free? At least
    according to the Judeo-Christian view, don't I have to pay for this public
    good by sacrificing coveting my neighbor's wife, dishonoring my mother and
    father, lying to any and everyone, not killing the morons who cross me up,
    and all the rest? Isn't there a cost in "turning the other cheek?" These may
    be costs I pay willingly, but they are costs nonetheless.

    Jim Eaton



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Mon Aug 29 2005 - 13:17:24 CDT